top of page

CONVERSATIONS
WITH GOD

The Valley of the Shadow of Death: Public Failure

​

​​

Download PDF

Archived Conversations with God​​​​​​

​​​​​​

​​

​​​​​

 

Day 1 

The Danger of Overconfidence

When We Think We Are Stronger Than We Really Are

​

Key Scripture: 1 Corinthians 10:12​

“Therefore let anyone who thinks that he stands take heed lest he fall.” (ESV)

​

There is something particularly frightening about Peter’s denial of Christ. Peter was not a peripheral figure. He was not someone who was only vaguely attached to Christ, or even more, an enemy. Peter was part of Christ’s inner circle. He had walked with Him, witnessed His miracles, heard His teaching, and confessed Him as the Christ, the Son of the living God.

​

And yet, when the moment of testing came, Peter denied even knowing Him.

​

Perhaps the most surprising part of the story is that Peter confidently believed he would never do such a thing.

​

When Jesus told His disciples that they would all fall away that night, Peter immediately objected. "Peter answered him, “Though they all fall away because of you, I will never fall away.”" (Matthew 26:33).

​

Peter was confident. He was sincere. He loved Jesus. But he had made a serious mistake: he had placed too much confidence in his own strength in spite of Jesus’ warnings.

​

The Difference Between Sincerity and Strength

​

Peter's problem was not that he lacked affection for Jesus. His problem was that he overestimated his ability to remain faithful under pressure. His evaluation of his own strength, his power to resist, was severely inaccurate. 

​

He was essentially saying, "I know what everyone else might do, but I know what I will do. I am different."

​

Jesus responded by telling Peter that before the rooster crowed, he would deny Him three times (Matthew 26:34).

​

Peter continued to insist that even if he had to die with Jesus, he would never deny Him. Matthew tells us that all the other disciples said the same thing (Matthew 26:35).

​

The tragedy is that these men were making promises about a future they could not control.

​

We sometimes make the same mistake.

​

We imagine that certain temptations could never affect us. We tell ourselves that we would never compromise our convictions, that we would never become involved in a particular sin, or that we would never abandon our faith when circumstances become difficult.

​

We look at the failures of others and quietly reassure ourselves that we are different, not understanding that they are telling themselves the same thing.

​

But Scripture repeatedly warns us against this kind of confidence.

​

Paul writes in 1 Corinthians 10:12, "Therefore let anyone who thinks that he stands take heed lest he fall.."

​

Notice that Paul does not say that the person who is standing should be afraid of falling. He says that the person who thinks he stands should take heed. The danger is not spiritual strength. The danger is believing that our strength is sufficient without continued dependence upon God.

​

Peter's confidence was not grounded in the sustaining power of Christ. It was grounded in his own assessment of himself.

​

Spiritual Strength Requires Spiritual Dependence

​

One of the most important lessons from Peter's failure is that our greatest spiritual vulnerability may come when we believe we are least vulnerable.

​

Consider the events of that evening.

​

Before Peter ever denied Jesus, he failed to remain watchful in prayer. In the Garden of Gethsemane, Jesus instructed His disciples to watch and pray so that they would not enter into temptation (Matthew 26:36–41).

​

Peter slept.

​

Jesus understood what Peter did not: the coming trial would require spiritual preparation that Peter had neglected.

​

Jesus said, "The spirit indeed is willing, but the flesh is weak" (Matthew 26:41).

​

This statement describes the human condition remarkably well. We can sincerely desire to do what is right while underestimating the weakness of our own flesh.

​

We can intend to be patient but become angry. We can intend to be generous but become selfish. We can intend to speak truthfully but become dishonest when the truth becomes inconvenient. We can intend to stand for Christ but become silent when doing so threatens our reputation.

​

Good intentions are not the same thing as spiritual preparedness.

​

This is why the Christian life requires more than making resolutions. It requires daily dependence upon God.

​

Consider the ordinary disciplines that strengthen our faith: prayer, Scripture reading, worship, fellowship with other believers, confession of sin, and obedience in the small decisions of everyday life.

​

These practices do not earn God's favor. They help keep our hearts attentive to Him and train us to recognize and resist temptation.

​

The person who neglects these ordinary means of spiritual growth should not be surprised when extraordinary pressure reveals extraordinary weakness.

​

Recognize Your Vulnerabilities

​

Peter's story also teaches us the importance of honestly recognizing our weaknesses.

​

Some of us are particularly vulnerable to temptation when we are tired. Others struggle when they are angry, discouraged, lonely, or under financial pressure.

​

Some are easily influenced by the approval of others. Others become vulnerable when their professional reputation, personal comfort, or relationships are threatened.

​

We cannot prepare for temptation if we refuse to acknowledge where we are vulnerable.

​

James 1:14 teaches that a person is tempted when drawn away by his own desires. Temptation does not look exactly the same for everyone.

​

This means we should be honest with ourselves about the circumstances in which we are most likely to compromise our convictions.

​

It also means that we should be careful about placing ourselves unnecessarily in situations where temptation is likely to overcome us.

​

Paul instructs Timothy to flee youthful lusts (2 Timothy 2:22). Sometimes the most spiritual response is not to demonstrate how strong we are but to remove ourselves from the opportunity to sin.

​

A Better Kind of Confidence

​

The answer to Peter's overconfidence is not that Christians should live in constant insecurity, doubting whether they will remain faithful.

​

Rather, we must learn to place our confidence in the right place.

​

Paul writes in Philippians 4:13, "I can do all things through Christ who strengthens me."

​

Our confidence should not be in our own ability to withstand every temptation. It should be in the faithfulness and power of the God who sustains us.

​

Peter eventually learned this lesson. The man who once believed he could stand through his own determination became a man who understood the necessity of God's grace.

​

His later writings encourage believers to be sober and vigilant because their adversary, the devil, walks about seeking whom he may devour (1 Peter 5:8). Peter knew firsthand that spiritual carelessness has consequences.

​

But he also knew that God gives grace to the humble (1 Peter 5:5).

​

The Christian who recognizes his weakness and depends upon God is in a far stronger position than the Christian who believes he has no weakness.

​

Personal Reflection

  1. Are there areas of your spiritual life where you have become overly confident in your own ability to resist temptation?

  2. What circumstances tend to make you most vulnerable to compromising your convictions?

  3. Have you neglected any ordinary spiritual disciplines that help you remain close to God?

  4. What would it look like to replace self-confidence with greater dependence upon Christ this week?

​

​​

Day 2

The Courage to Stand with Christ

When the Approval of Others Becomes More Important Than Faithfulness to God

​

Key Scripture: Galatians 1:10

"For am I now seeking the approval of man, or of God? Or am I trying to please man? If I were still trying to please man, I would not be a servant of Christ." (ESV)

​

One of the most uncomfortable aspects of Peter's denial of Jesus is how understandable and applicable to our own lives the failure appears.

​

Peter was not standing before a Roman governor being threatened with execution. He was not being asked to renounce Christ in a formal courtroom. He was not facing a military tribunal or a mob demanding his death.

​

He was standing in a courtyard.

​

A servant girl recognized him. She asked whether he had been with Jesus. Peter denied it.

​

A little later, another person recognized him. Again, Peter denied knowing Jesus.

​

Finally, those standing nearby observed that his speech gave him away. They insisted that he must have been one of Jesus' followers. Peter responded with increasingly forceful denials, even invoking a curse upon himself (Matthew 26:69–74).

​

It is remarkable that the man who had hours before drawn a sword to defend Jesus was now unwilling even to acknowledge that he knew Him.

​

What happened?

​

Peter became more concerned with what other people thought of him than with remaining faithful to Christ.

​

The Powerful Influence of Social Pressure

​

We often imagine that abandoning our convictions requires a dramatic decision. We picture someone consciously deciding to reject God or abandon everything they believe.

​

But Peter's experience demonstrates that compromise often happens through a series of smaller decisions.

​

A subtle change in the balance of power may be enough, and a few small observations or decisions might get us there.

​

Peter had seen Jesus do mighty things. Peter had seen the triumphal entry earlier that week. Jesus seemed powerful. More powerful than those around him. Until he didn’t.

​

The same pattern can happen in our lives.

​

Our perception of the relative power, importance, and influence of Christ vs. the people around us is a very dynamic thing. We give credence to the stories of Christ and his power in one moment, then in another we worry about what the people around us think of us. 

​

Unless we are always strengthening our perception of the power of Christ, we will most likely be more impressed with the strength of the world.

​

When Jesus submitted to authority of those arresting him, Peter found his faith in Christ shaken. How do you fair when Christ does something unexpected in your life? Does your faith hold or does it falter?

​

The Fear of Being Different

​

Social pressure can be very powerful, and one reason it is so powerful is that human beings naturally desire acceptance.

​

We want to belong. We want to be respected. We want our friends, families, coworkers, and communities to think well of us.

​

There is nothing inherently wrong with wanting good relationships with other people. Scripture teaches us to live peaceably with others as much as possible (Romans 12:18).

​

The problem comes when our desire for acceptance begins to determine our obedience.

​

Jesus warned His disciples that following Him would sometimes bring opposition. In John 15:18–20, He explained that the world would sometimes hate His followers because it had first hated Him.

​

The implication is clear: we cannot make universal approval the measure of whether we are living faithfully.

​

Sometimes doing what is right will make us unpopular.

​

Sometimes honesty will cost us an opportunity. Sometimes moral convictions will make us appear old-fashioned. Sometimes identifying ourselves with Christ will invite criticism.

​

The question is not whether we will experience pressure. The question is what we will do when that pressure comes.

​

The Quiet Denials of Modern Life

​

Most Christians will never be asked to stand before a crowd and formally deny Jesus.

​

But there are many ways we can deny Him through our conduct.

​

We deny Him when we knowingly live in a way that contradicts the faith we profess.

​

We deny Him when we conceal our Christian convictions because we are embarrassed by them.

​

We deny Him when we allow our desire for popularity to silence our commitment to biblical truth.

​

We deny Him when we behave differently around unbelieving friends than we do around fellow Christians because we want to avoid appearing religious.

​

We deny Him when we refuse to acknowledge His influence in our lives because doing so might make us uncomfortable.

​

These are not all equally serious situations, and wisdom is necessary in knowing when and how to speak. Christians are not called to be needlessly argumentative or offensive.

​

Peter's story is not an instruction to seek confrontation. It is a warning not to abandon our convictions when confrontation comes.

​

Colossians 4:5–6 instructs believers to walk in wisdom toward outsiders and to let their speech always be gracious. We are called to combine courage with gentleness.

​

1 Peter 3:15 similarly instructs us to be ready to give an answer for the hope within us, doing so with meekness and fear.

​

We should not be ashamed of Christ, but neither should we use our faith as an excuse to treat others without kindness.

​

Courage Is Developed Before the Moment of Testing

​

Peter's failure also reminds us that courage is not usually created in the moment it is needed.

​

It is developed through a lifetime of smaller decisions.

​

If we consistently compromise our convictions in minor situations, we should not expect to become courageous when the stakes are higher.

​

Conversely, when we practice faithfulness in ordinary circumstances, we develop habits that prepare us for more difficult circumstances.

​

Consider Daniel. Long before he faced the threat of the lions' den, he had already determined that he would not defile himself with the king's food (Daniel 1:8). His courage in the dramatic moment was rooted in convictions established in ordinary life.

​

The same principle applies to us.

​

We develop courage when we tell the truth even when lying would be easier. We develop courage when we refuse to participate in gossip even when everyone else is doing it. We develop courage when we acknowledge our faith naturally rather than hiding it.

 

We develop courage when we choose obedience over convenience.

​

These decisions may not seem particularly heroic, but they prepare us for the moments when faithfulness becomes costly.

​

Remember Whose Approval Matters Most

​

Ultimately, the question Peter faced in that courtyard was a question of whose approval mattered most and who was truly God, the King of Kings and the Lord of Lords.

​

Did he value the acceptance of the people around the fire more than his relationship with Jesus? Did he respect their power more than the power of Christ?

​

In that moment, he chose to fear and seek the approval of people.

​

Jesus would later teach that whoever acknowledges Him before others will be acknowledged by Him before the Father (Matthew 10:32–33).

​

This is not a call to boast about our Christianity. It is a call to live openly and faithfully as people who belong to Christ.

​

We must remember that the approval of people is temporary. Reputations change. Friendships change. Public opinion changes.

​

But our relationship with Christ is of eternal importance.

​

The next time you face the temptation to remain silent, compromise a conviction, or conceal your allegiance to Jesus, remember Peter in that courtyard.

​

And remember that you do not have to make the same choice.

​

Ask God for the courage to stand with Christ, not because you are stronger than everyone else, but because He is worthy of your faithfulness.

​

Personal Reflection

  1. In what situations are you most tempted to conceal your Christian convictions?

  2. Have you ever compromised a biblical principle because you were afraid of what someone would think?

  3. What small decisions could you make this week to strengthen your courage and consistency?

  4. How can you become more courageous in your witness while remaining gracious and respectful toward others?

​

​

To Be Continued!

bottom of page